MacDonald Academy of Martial Arts

Kenpo Karate, Krav Maga, and Fitness for the Boston / Watertown area

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Sign up for our newsletter!
GET STARTED!
  • Home
  • GET STARTED
  • Seminars & Events
  • News & Articles
    • Announcements & News
    • Kenpo News
    • Krav Maga News
  • About
    • The Academy
    • Our Instructors
    • What People Are Saying
  • Programs
    • Youth Kenpo Karate
    • Adult Kenpo Karate
    • Krav Maga
    • Law Enforcement
  • Class Schedule
  • Student Area
    • Kenpo Student Area
    • Krav Maga Student Area
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Krav Maga News / Training / Combatives / Developing Your “When”

Developing Your “When”

03.02.10 By Patrick 25 Comments

krav_countdown
One concept that sets Krav Maga apart from most other self-defense systems is that we consistently train from a position of disadvantage. The belief is that all techniques must work whether we are prepared or not, as most situations requiring us to defend ourselves occur suddenly and with little warning. If we only trained from a prepared position (our fighting stance), we would either be delayed to action or—much worse—freeze when caught off guard.

Part of our training involves practicing both offensive and defensive techniques from what we call passive or neutral position. Beyond developing lighting-fast reaction, not much forethought must go into defensive techniques; the decision to act has been made for us by the attacker. Launching a preemptive assault, however, is a very different situation. We must consider the how?, the when?, and the what then? (the immediate and longer-term consequences) of such an action.


Krav Maga instructor Jeff Jimmo teaches the "when" concept in his self-protection seminars. In a nutshell, you must decide at what point when is now, or what the trigger is that will make you launch a preemptive attack to diffuse a souring situation. Is it a certain tone of voice or something about a person’s body positioning that will tell you it’s time to fight? Or should you wait until the other person makes a physical move towards violence? When is when? There is no correct answer other than "before it’s too late". This obviously varies by situation and by individual. Also be aware that acting too soon may very well worsen the situation if there’s a chance for verbal deescalation.

Regardless of when you choose to spring to action, you will most likely be doing it from a passive stance. Here’s a review of the three passive stance variations*:

Passive Neutral Stance

PASSIVE NEUTRAL STANCE
MINDSET: Low state of readiness or awareness; training mindset.
POSITION: Stand with feet approximately shoulder width apart (or less), with arms hanging to the
sides or up in a ready position. Feet should not be outside shoulder width when standing neutral.

Passive Natural Stance

PASSIVE NATURAL STANCE
MINDSET: Low state of readiness or awareness.
POSITION: A normal standing position that is specific to the individual based upon personal attributes such as dominant hand or weight shift in feet. Examples: You may tilt your hip distributing 80% body weight onto one leg, cross your legs or arms, place your hands on your hips, hold onto something such as a gym bag or grocery bag, etc.

Passive Tactical Stance

PASSIVE TACTICAL STANCE
MINDSET: High state of readiness or awareness.
POSITION: This position is what we often refer to as our "modified fighting stance". Accordingly, the feet are the same as fighting stance with perhaps a little bit less bend in the knees. The hands are in a position of tactical readiness similar to a fighting stance but less obvious to the opponent.

Last Friday night we trained four combatives from these less-than-ideal positions:

  • Straight Punch
  • Elbow
  • Hook Punch
  • Groin Kick

Another very powerful combative to add to this list is the forward hammerfist from the passive tactical stance. The goal of all these strikes is to inflict maximal damage to the threat as quickly as possible. These strikes must either incapacitate the threat or be so spectacular that the immediate threat and any surrounding threats are unable or unwilling to engage further.

[I’d be remiss if I didn’t inject a short disclaimer here that a preemptive attack may open a barrel of legal consequences, so these techniques should not be used haphazardly. The first and best defense is always avoidance, followed by escape. Only when danger is imminent and there is no escape should you preemptively strike someone else, especially with these very powerful techniques. Please review the use of force post and do your own research. Above all, exercise good judgment.]

Beyond this, there are many psychological aspects to such a scenario. Jeff Jimmo likes to ask a question right before he strikes, getting the other person’s mind to take a split-second detour to distract him from the forthcoming KO shot.

Bad Guy: I’m gonna break yer face!
You: What time is it?
Bad Guy: Wha—
—BANG!

There’s a lot to these concepts, and we plan to explore them in the coming weeks, helping everyone develop both the psychological aspect of their “when” as well as the technical aspect of powerful strikes from a passive position.

 


*Ref: © Krav Maga Association of America, Inc. and Krav Maga Worldwide, Inc.

 

Filed Under: Combatives, Krav Maga News, Krav Maga Technique Library, Self-Defense, Training Tagged With: "when", 360 Defense, fundamentals, legal, passive/neutral position, situational awareness, use of force

Questions? Comments? Post 'em Here! Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments

  1. ai generated music cleaner says

    07.10.26 at 21:23

    With suno artifact cleaner, youu can fix
    suno artifacts easily. If you want to fix suno audio issues, this
    ai music cleaner is perfect. Suno vvocal cleaner and aii music voczl
    cleaner can make yyour music sound clearer. Fiind verified suno artifact
    cleaner options at ai generated music cleaner.

    Reply
  2. Peter sox says

    07.11.26 at 23:34

    For a long time I have been researching rare coins and antiques. I love discovering the history behind old coins and collectible antiques.
    While exploring different websites I discovered https://groshi.xyz . The website looked very promising. There was quite a bit of informative articles about coins.
    I especially liked the practical content. Even though the project is still developing, it has great potential.
    It seems that the project will be fully available soon. I’ll definitely come back, because I believe there will be a lot more interesting publications for coin collectors.
    For anyone interested in numismatics or antiques, I think visiting this site. I’m looking forward to seeing how the project grows.

    Reply
  3. sergey young investor s says

    07.12.26 at 10:15

    Interesting blog! Is your theme custom made or did
    you download it from somewhere? A design like yours
    with a few simple tweeks would really make my blog shine.
    Please let me know where you got your design. Kudos

    Reply
  4. VegaZone says

    07.12.26 at 23:52

    I’m from Australia and not long ago I chose to test out https://payinnv.tech simply from a sense of curiosity. Initially, I was drawn to the site as a whole: everything looks rather clean, it isn’t hard to navigate, and the games are quick to locate. For me, this is a crucial detail, because when the layout is overloaded or awkward, the urge to keep playing tends to fade pretty quickly.

    I originally discovered VegaZone when hunting for platforms with more convenient navigation and crash games. Ultimately, I decided to test the format and find out how comfortable normal gaming sessions felt like there. As far as that goes, my experience was generally positive: everything feels clear, with no excessive overload, and the platform feels calm in general.

    I also appreciated is that the platform offers a solid range of games, and you don’t get the feeling of being limited in your options. It’s easy to jump in for a quick visit, or spend more time whenever you want. I’ve always liked platforms where you don’t need to spend ages learning the layout and can quickly jump into exactly what caught your eye.

    My favourite part on this platform were definitely the crash-style games. For me, I like them far more than classic slots, because they have a different pace and the gameplay seems more alive. There’s a greater level of involvement in the gameplay, there are moments of decision, and as a result playing is more fun to me than simply spinning slots in the same rhythm.

    I personally usually play more steadily and more often than not choose lower multipliers, as opposed to constantly hunting for some huge x’s. It just feels better to me in terms of feel: gameplay flow more evenly, you can stay in the game longer and appreciate the process itself. When you’re not attempting to turn every bet into a “”win big or go home””, the whole thing feels much more relaxed.

    Over the long run, this playstyle is what I prefer the most. Sticking to smaller targets, it’s possible to play at your own pace, not burning through your bankroll and without turning every session into a constant hunt after a big win. Personally, this is what makes each session more relaxed.

    In general, VegaZone has left quite a pleasant experience as a convenient platform for calm gaming and everyday sessions free from unnecessary hassle. If crash games, a simple design and a more low-key approach is what you’re after, VegaZone could work well perfectly.

    Reply
  5. umar kremlev biyografisi says

    07.13.26 at 02:59

    Howdy would you mind stating which blog platform you’re using?
    I’m looking to start my own blog soon but I’m having a hard time selecting between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal.
    The reason I ask is because your layout seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something
    completely unique. P.S My apologies for being
    off-topic but I had to ask!

    Reply
  6. PerryLerge says

    07.14.26 at 02:48

    На opppalldh.space представлений актуальний каталог надійних джерел.

    Тут ви знайдете достовірну інформацію з аналітикою, політикою, економікою, і ключовими подіями країни.

    Без інформаційного сміття і нічого зайвого. Ідеальне місце для тих, хто хоче отримувати об’єктивну картину без шуму.

    Reply
  7. mastering suno tracks says

    07.15.26 at 15:05

    Suno’s AI music cleaner is a great tool to clean Suno AI tracks.

    It improves vocals and makes the music sound much more natural.
    Perfect for anyone nreding to fix Suno vocals.
    Visit mastering suno tracks to learn more.

    Reply
  8. RikaCow says

    07.15.26 at 20:06

    Немало читателей иногда заходят в интернет в надежде найти текст, которое не просто убьет время, а заставит задуматься и свежие инсайты. На https://streetmusic.com.ua/ – streetmusic.com.ua как раз аккумулируется такой контент, где уживаются анализы кинолент, биографии артистов и психологические зарисовки. Материалы написаны так, что погружаешься и замечаешь, что мысленно визуализируешь, как воплощается в аудио или на дисплее.

    Сайт не пытается удивить сенсационностью каждой строчки, зато формирует атмосферу, будто общаешься с единомышленником, который только что зацікавився питанням и теперь делится находками. Гортаешь страницы и наблюдаешь, как кінематограф плавно стає психологією, а музыка помогает лучше понять особенности действующих лиц. Такой формат подходит для тех, кто ценит вдумчивый подход.

    В кінці робочого дня или на вихідних, когда есть запрос на щось глибоке, многие заходят сюда и находят именно то, что нужно. Тексти зберігають баланс между інформативністю та емоційністю, поэтому не втомлюють.

    Reply
  9. mcaofiowa.org says

    07.16.26 at 05:43

    Fix sno artifacts on your tracks quickly using this suno audio cleaner and improove
    suno sound quality now.

    Here is my blog post … mcaofiowa.org

    Reply
  10. suno sound quality bad says

    07.16.26 at 06:26

    {Suno artifact remover is a game changer for anyone looking to imprkve audio quality.|If you want to fix suno artifahts and boost sounnd
    clarity, suno aai artifact rmover works great.|Removing suno artifacts has never been easier with the suno audio cleaner tool.|Forr
    clean suno ai tracks, the suno artifact cleanedr
    provides excellent results.|Fixing suno audio quality
    issues is simple using the suno track cleaner approach.|The ai music cleaner online free
    options help remove unwanted suno aii artifacts quickly.|Suno
    mastering tools offer an effective wway to enhance suno sound
    quality.|If you struggle with suno sound quality bad issues,
    tryy the suno vocal cleaner.|Make suno vocals sund human and clear by
    using an aii music vocal cleaner.|Improving suno audio quality iis easier with reliable aai generated music cleaners.|To clean suno ai artifacts
    and fix vocals, use a trusted suno mastering fre service.|For enhanced suno audio quality, consider mastering suno tracks with the
    right tools.|Use the suno mastering online solutions to remove artifacts and polish sound.|A good ai music artifact remover
    can fix suno auio problems efficiently.|Trry suno artifact remover if you want to clean suno ai tracks with miknimal effort.|Check out suno sound quality bad for the best tools to remove
    artifacts from suno and improve audio.|Cleaning suno ai music tracks
    also enhances mastering and ovcerall track quality.|The suno aai artifact remover is perfect for
    making suno vocals sound morte natural.|Suno artifact cleaner and ai music
    audio cleaner combined provide top-notch fixes.|To fix suno vocals and improve sound, try a
    free ai song cleanerr specialized for suno.|Suno mastering free options can help restore the
    full quality of your suno tracks.|Keep your suno audio quality high by regularly removng
    artifacts with the right tools.|Achieve professional-level suno audio quality by mastering suno tracks online.|{Thiss aii music
    cleaning technology is ideal forr anyone dealing with suno
    artifacts.|Suno artifact remover annd cleaner tools solve most common sun audio issues.|Free
    ai music cleaner tools online do a fantastic job cleaning
    suno tracks.|Use an ai music vocal cleaner to make your suno vocals lively and human-like.|Suno mastering tools elevate audio quality by fixing
    all suno artifact problems.|Remove unwanted suno ai artofacts
    fast with an effective audio cleaning tool.|Make suno vocals sound hhuman and imporove overall track qualitty at no cost.|Fix suno audio quality issues easily wirh the suno track cleaner solution.|The suno artifact cleaner works perrfectly forr cleaning ai generated music.|For those
    struggvling with suno audio quality, the ai music artifact remover
    helps.|Using a suyno artifact remover iis the key to
    mastering suno tracks with clear sound.|Improve suno sound quality by
    removing artifacts with a trustwothy ai audio cleaner.|Effective suno ai artifact removers are essential to clean suno aai music online.|Suno
    mastering online tools provide the quickeet fix for suno audio aand vocals.|An ai generated music
    cleaner coupled with suno mastering enhances sound quality.|Looking tto clean your suno track?
    Use an ai musi cpeaner specialized for suno.|Find the fastest way to fix suno vocals and remove artifacts wiuth ai music cleaner.|Sunoo artifact remover is the best
    choice for improving suno audio quality overall.|Improve your sumo adio track by
    remolving artifacts with ann ai music cleaner.|Fix suno
    audio problems fat with a dedicated suno artifact cleaner and mastering.|{Discover
    how to make suno vocals sound human with ai music vocal cleaners.|Suno mastering free tools provide great help for removing suno
    artifacts.|Upgrade your suno track’s quality byy removing
    unwanted artifacts usding ai.|Suno artifct remober tools are essential for professional suno audio mastering.|Clean suno ai tfacks
    effortlessly using an advanced suno artifact cleaner.|Suuno mastering tools
    online help improve the clarity and richness of suno audio.|Enhance your aii generated muusic
    by fixing suno artifacts and improving vocals.|Get ridd of suno
    ai artifacts for free with reliable aii music cleaning solutions.|Use a
    suno vocal cleaner to fix and humanijze vocals in your suyno audio.|Remove suno artifacts quickly and efficiently with an ai music audio cleaner.|Sunno audio cleaner tools are perfect for hose looking tto
    improve sound quality.|Achieve studio-level suno mastering by removin all
    unwanted audio artifacts.|Improve suno sound quality badd issues by mastering your tracks using ai tools.|Try suno
    artifact remover and suno mastering to get top audio quality.|Remove artifacts from suno effectively usng aai music cleaner online free tools.|Suno mastering onlne results
    in better audio quality and artifact-free vocals.|Make suno
    vocals sound human and natural with advanced ai vocal cleaning.|Fix suno audio
    quality and vocals easily by mastering suno tracks online.|Ai music artifact remover technology is a must-have for clean suno audio.|Get professional sun mastering results that fix
    all track artifact issues.|Suno artifact remover
    helps improve suno audio quality with minimal effort.|Clean suno ai
    music tracks using the best ai music cleaner tools
    available.|Mastering suno tracks is esy when you
    remoce artifacts with quality ai cleaners.|Suno track ccleaner tools online offer fast
    fixes for suno audio quality problems.|Improve sunoo audio quality
    by using an ai music cldaner dedicated to suno.|Fix suno vocals and sound quality bad
    issues with specialized ai music cleaners.|Clean annd mmaster
    your suno tracks online with free suno artifact
    remover tools.|Achieve better sound quality with suno mastering
    free services and arrtifact removal.|}

    Reply
  11. Almeda says

    07.16.26 at 07:06

    For those struggling with Suno artifacts, the Suno artifact cleaner is a must-have.
    It helped me remove those pesky Suno AI musiic glitches quickly.

    Feel free to surf to my webb site: Almeda

    Reply
  12. Edwardhen says

    07.16.26 at 17:25

    Коли заходиш на institute.lviv.ua, миттєво помічаєш, як різноманітність матеріалів не дає нудьгувати. Сайт не зводиться однією темою, а змішує історії з культури, практичні поради для дому, відомості про оборону та щоденні турботи. Саме ця суміш робить його виділеним серед інших ресурсів, адже будь-хто відшукає тут щось близьке саме собі.

    Матеріали на https://www.institute.lviv.ua/ – institute.lviv.ua часто починаються з конкретних подій, які турбують людей сьогодні, і розкривають ширший контекст. Такий підхід дозволяє не лише повідомляти, а заглиблювати в деталі, які запам’ятовуються.

    Читачі заходять ще раз сюди, бо статті не намагаються втиснути все в холодну інформацію, а передають про реальне життя з його тонкощами та неочікуваними паралелями.

    Як сайт поєднує історію з сучасними викликами

    Однією з сильних сторін institute.lviv.ua стає талант з’єднувати історію з сучасністю. Статті про культурну спадщину, наприклад пасхальні звичаї, не закінчуються на загальних відомостях. Вони заглиблюються в те, як історичні історії не зникають в сучасних родинах, як змінюються символи з роками. Читач розуміє, що навіть прості речі на кшталт шоколадних фігурок мають давнішу історію.

    Паралельно з культурними матеріалами виникають тексти, які стосуються захисту держави. Розмова про системи ППО, таких як IRIS-T, розкривається через призму сьогоднішніх подій. Автори роз’яснюють складні аспекти доступною мовою, викладають про історію створення ракети та її значення для захисту неба. Це не просто техніка, а оповідь про те, як інженерні досягнення відображаються на щоденне життя.

    Таке з’єднання допомагає зрозуміти, що культурна сфера й оборона тісно пов’язані. Вони зливаються в одному суспільстві, яке намагається утримати свою ідентичність у складні часи. Читач, який шукає контекст, отримує його без зайвого пафосу.

    Подібний стиль спостерігається й в інших текстах. Вони не нав’язують думку, а показують різні грані явища, залишаючи місце для власних висновків. Саме тому матеріали сприймаються природно, ніби жива розмова.

    Reply
  13. Willispels says

    07.17.26 at 04:52

    Сучасний медіапростір насичений різними джерелами, в якому кожне намагається привернути увагу своєю унікальністю. З-поміж них plandiy.com.ua виділяється умінням подавати події так, наче вони трапляються прямо зараз, без непотрібних пауз або ж перекручувань. Користувачі часто приходять знову сюди, тому що відшукують тут гармонійне поєднання між швидкістю та детальністю розкриття.

    Особливо приваблює те, як https://plandiy.com.ua/ – plandiy.com.ua природно об’єднує локальні українські сюжети з світовими тенденціями, надаючи можливість відвідувачам оперативно знаходити відповіді в тому, що трапляється поруч. Такий спосіб робить сайт не лише переліком подій, а своєрідним навігатором по сьогоднішнім справам.

    Reply
  14. casinos que no pagan says

    07.17.26 at 05:52

    Algo que conviene saber es la riesgo de cada tragamoneda. Las tragamonedas tranquilas ofrecen premios chicos pero frecuentes, recomendables
    para partidas de muchas horas.

    Reply
  15. Marcoup says

    07.17.26 at 09:00

    The most addictive slot of this year. Play now and see why! Spin to Win Here -> psee.io/8qtelp

    Reply
  16. 2huellas.es says

    07.17.26 at 16:02

    Burbujas Catalunya combinan modernidad y naturaleza a lla perfección.

    Feel free to visit my web blog; 2huellas.es

    Reply
  17. hotel burbuja says

    07.17.26 at 19:35

    Si buscas alojamiento en burbujas, no dudes en explorar opciones en Bardenas
    Reales, Murcia o incluso en Barcelona. La sensación de estar en una hotel burbuja es
    inolvidable.

    Reply
  18. dormir en burbujas cataluña says

    07.17.26 at 20:20

    La bubble experience en Madrid y los hoteles burbuja dormir en burbujas cataluña Ronda o Villena se
    están convirtiendo enn alojamientos muy valorados por quienes desean combinar naturaleza y diseño.
    Vale la pena conocerlos.

    Reply
  19. jet ski puerto colon says

    07.19.26 at 09:52

    From cheap jet ski puerto colon ski rentals near me tto premium tours
    like Extreme Jet Ski Tenerife, there’s a perfect
    match for every thrill-seeker.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. The Shirt Grab & Finishing the Fight — MacDonald Academy of Martial Arts Krav Maga says:
    03.19.10 at 10:09

    […] The “when” concept. If you can talk your way out of a scenario like this, by all means do so. If, however, you sense the shirt grab is just a precursor to greater violence, when is now. […]

    Reply
  2. March 2010 Syllabus — MacDonald Academy of Martial Arts Krav Maga says:
    04.01.10 at 13:48

    […] 3Blue Belt – Level 4Brown Belt – Level 5ContactLinksAdvanced SearchSitemap « Developing Your “When” Congrats, Brian! […]

    Reply
  3. On being mentally prepared | MacDonald Academy of Martial Arts | Kenpo Karate · Krav Maga · Fitness | Self-Defense for Kids & Adults in Boston / Watertown, MA says:
    08.24.11 at 08:01

    […] but what about our mental training? One key element in the mental preparation is knowing when. At what point to you decide to engage physically? At what point do you decide that the “Hey […]

    Reply
  4. Two Excellent Sam Harris Essays on Self-Defense | Boston Metro Kenpo Karate · Krav Maga · Fitness | MacDonald Academy of Martial Arts says:
    03.30.12 at 16:10

    […] Developing Your “When” […]

    Reply
  5. Darren Laur’s “Ritualized Combative Signs” | Boston Metro Kenpo Karate · Krav Maga · Fitness | MacDonald Academy of Martial Arts says:
    04.03.12 at 12:06

    […] you cannot avoid a confrontation entirely, being able to read these precursors and developing your “when” are at the core of our self-defense […]

    Reply
  6. Krav Maga Scenarios 11.03.12 | Boston Metro Kenpo Karate · Krav Maga · Fitness | MacDonald Academy of Martial Arts says:
    10.31.12 at 12:48

    […] out this post for more […]

    Reply

Important Posts: Read These!

  • Academy Announcements & News
  • Academy Closings
  • Academy Policy Updates

Archives

Categories

Latest Academy News

Easy Like Sunday Morning

Fall 2020 Live & Online Schedules

COVID-19 Update 03/20/20

Read More Academy News»

What People Are Saying

Magazine Covers

We're proud of our achievements as a school and in the community. Awards: We've been voted … [Read More...]

Our Instructors

Our instructors are highly trained and certified in their respective disciplines. Brian … Learn More

Magazine Covers

What People Are Saying

We're proud of our achievements as a school and in the community. Awards: We've been voted "Best of the Best" Martial Arts in Watertown - from 2003 through 2013! MSA and GKM are survey … Learn More

Contact Us

MacDonald Academy of Martial Arts
6 Riverside St
Watertown, MA 02472 · USA
phone: 617.923.4248
Click here for directions and e-mail
Sign up for our newsletter!

  • Announcements & Academy News
  • Kenpo News & Articles
  • Krav Maga News & Articles
  • * SEMINARS & EVENTS *

Copyright © 2026 · Privacy Policy · SITEMAP
Site Development by Patrick Sanders